Business Email Compromise (BEC) is a serious type of email fraud in which attackers use fake or compromised business email accounts to deceive employees into sending money or sharing any kind of sensitive information. By following the correct steps for a BEC (Business Email Compromise) investigation helps investigators to easily understand how a fraud occurred, quickly identifying any kind of suspicious messages and allows for the collection of useful evidence linked to the emails. A proper BEC investigation begins with reviewing email headers, searching for suspicious keywords, thoroughly examining sender’s details and analyzing any attachments.

These BEC investigation steps also help you to connect related emails and details of the attacker’s communication pattern. In this kind of case there is one reliable tool particularly for organizations who are handling email evidence they can trust MailPro+ Investigation solution powered by SysTools which can make this process very simple and organized through email header analysis and advanced keyword search.

What Is Business Email Compromise (BEC)?

Business Email Compromise (BEC) is a type of cybercrime in which attackers act as a trusted person or they take control of a legal email account. Their targets are generally employees who handle payments, invoices, payroll or any kind of confidential business information.

Let’s take an example to understand this. Suppose there is an employee who receives email that appears to come from the company’s CEO and yes it looks like a completely genuine email and requests an urgent payment. Attackers generally try to send these emails with such a high level of professionalism so that they may seem absolutely authentic however the sender here could actually be an attacker who is using a fake email address or a compromised account.

There are common types of BEC attacks and these are:

  • CEO fraud: The attacker shows as a senior executive and requests an urgent payment.
  • Invoice fraud: Criminals change payment details in invoice and then request company to transfer money to a different account.
  • Account compromise: Attackers use tricks to gain access to business email accounts and then they use them to send fraudulent messages.
  • Payroll diversion: Employees receive fake payroll updates in which attackers ask them to modify their bank account details.
  • Vendor impersonation: Here attackers pose as a trusted supplier and he sends fake payment instructions.

How to Investigate a Suspected BEC Attack

A successful BEC investigation needs more than reading the suspicious email. Investigators need to examine the original message, verify sender information, search related communications and also need to keep relevant evidence safe for further use. Find below the important BEC investigation steps which you need to follow.

Step 1: First Secure Original Email Evidence

You should firstly start by collecting all suspicious email in its original format. Here you must not depend only on screenshots or copied email text as these are not containing any technical information that are later needed for proper lawful investigation.

So you must keep the original email files including formats such as EML or MSG along with its available attachments and related messages too. You can also:

  • Keep a record when a suspicious email was received.
  • Note recipient’s and sender’s addresses.
  • Keep all related email conversations.
  • Keep copies of original evidence and ensure they remain untouched.
  • Record who collected and handled the evidence.

This creates a strong and reliable starting point for the email fraud investigation and helps you to completely maintain evidence integrity.

Step 2: Analyze Email Headers to Verify the Sender

Email header analysis – This is one of the most important BEC investigation steps. The reason behind this is they help investigators to complete examination of all the technical details behind a message.

The email header contains very useful information like how email was sent and delivered. It can include sender and recipient details, routing information, timestamps and also authentication results. Once you must pay attention to these important header fields as mentioned below in table:

Header Field What to Check
From Email address displayed as sender
Reply-To If the responses are directed to a different address
Return Path Address used for email delivery
Received Servers through which email passed
Message-ID Unique identifier assigned to the message
Authentication Results SPF, DKIM and DMARC authentication results

For example: Email may show you the CEO’s name but wait as here its actual sender address or Reply-To address may belong to any unrelated domain.

In order to know BEC Investigation Steps you must check SPF, DKIM and DMARC results which will help you to understand if the sending domain passed the relevant authentication checks. However, passing authentication does not itself prove that email is safe. A legitimate account that has been compromised can continue to send fraudulent messages.

If investigators want to review then they can use SysTools MailPro+ Email Investigation Software which is the one to do this task very easily. Find below download option click and download this utility on your Windows devices.

Download Now Purchase Now

The software allows users to open their email messages and let them quickly examine their Message Header, Properties and MIME views. This makes it easier not only for investigators but also for general users as well to review all the technical email information without depending only on the visible message content.

Step 3: Search Emails Using Suspicious Keywords

At the time of BEC investigation – searching emails with the right keywords can help you to find any kind of suspicious payment requests, fake invoices and also other related conversations.

You just need to start with common words that normally attackers use. This is very important BEC Investigation Steps by using advanced email search. Find these words below and search it:

  • Urgent payment
  • Updated bank details
  • Wire transfer
  • Change of account
  • Invoice attached
  • Confidential transaction
  • Immediate action required
  • Payment confirmation

One piece of advice I would like to share with you is that you should not depend on just one keyword. Try different combinations to find more related emails. For example: searching for bank details or updated accounts will help you to locate messages containing changed payment instructions.

When you are dealing with a large number of emails here the best idea is using a dedicated tool as suggested in step 2 as using this tool will allow you to use advanced email search where you will get multiple email search filters like AND, OR and NOT operators which will completely narrow the search output.

For example: Using invoice AND payment terms will help to find emails which are containing both terms. This saves your time and makes it easier to narrow down relevant messages during email fraud investigation.

Investigators must examine all the related emails and their attachments from previous email communications. These are fake invoices, payment instructions, purchase orders or other important business documents too. One must here check for the followings:

  • If changes in bank account or payment information.
  • For unexpected invoice numbers or amounts.
  • Check different supplier contact details.
  • Any unusual attachment names.
  • And differences between previous and recent email chats.

You must also review email threads to know clearly if the attacker joined existing conversation or started a new one. A single suspicious email may not explain the entire incident. Related messages can reveal when the attacker first contacted to the organization and how they asked for the payment.

Step 5: Build a Timeline of Suspicious Email Activity

My advice to investigators is to build a timeline as it is always helpful to understand all the sequence of the events that happen. Must collect important timestamps from original emails and then arrange them in chronological order. You can check the table below for detailed understanding.

Event What to Record
First suspicious contact Date and time of the first email
Follow up message Note time of next communication
Payment request When attacker ask you for money
Bank detail change When you shared new payment information
Employee response When employee replied or took any action

Now it will make everything easy for you to understand the sequences. Here you can compare timestamps, sender details and also Message-IDs of related emails. The simple logic behind this is to establish how the entire communication started.

These BEC investigation steps can also help organizations in understanding which accounts and employees have been affected.

Step 6: Prepare and Export Relevant Email Evidence

It’s finally time to prepare and export all the relevant email evidence for further review. Just select here important messages and attachments in place of collecting all unrelated emails. You must keep the original evidence available and document any export or processing activity.

SysTools software works in exactly the same way using this utility investigators can easily review sets of emails, select relevant messages and also they can export the evidence in various file formats. The export options allows users to get evidence in PDF with Bates numbering and CSV format.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. What are common signs of a BEC attack?

There are some common signs which you can observe are unexpected payment requests, urgent messages, change in bank details and doubtful Reply-To addresses.

Q2. How do you investigate a suspected BEC attack?

Just start the process by keeping original emails, auditing email headers, searching for any suspicious keywords, checking attachments, reviewing all the related conversations and then creating an event timeline is the best approach.

Q3. Why is email header analysis important in BEC investigations?

This is important BEC Investigation Steps as email header analysis is important as it helps investigators to quickly examine sender information, email routing, timestamps and other important communications as well.

Q4. Which keywords should investigators search for during a BEC investigation?

Generally investigators look for keywords that are related to urgent payment, updated bank details, wire transfer, invoice attached, payment confirmation and change of account. These are some of the useful keywords that investigators search.

Final Thoughts

A careful investigation is needed for a suspected BEC attack so you must start with securing the original emails, analysing complete email headers, checking attachments, searching for any kind of suspicious keywords as explained in step: 3 and building timeline of the happening events from start to end check step: 5 for details.

Following these BEC investigation steps will surely help organizations to understand the fraudulent communication and they can collect relevant evidence for further action.

For investigators who are handling large email collections they can choose a dedicated solution offered by SysTools that provides them with multiple features to make this task more easy and fast.